Welcome to Anna Maria's Pizzeria
At Anna Maria's Pizzeria, we celebrate the rich tradition of New York-style pizza in a welcoming and family-friendly atmosphere. Situated in Carrboro, NC, our pizzeria prioritizes quality and authentic flavors, offering a diverse menu that includes everything from delectable strombolis to vegetarian options. With the convenience of delivery and takeout, we cater to busy lives while still delivering unforgettable meals. Our inviting space is perfect for groups and kids, complete with outdoor seating and private parking. Whether you're a local or just passing through, a slice from Anna Maria’s promises to transport you back to the bustling streets of New York City.
Anna Maria's Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings
We order takeout from here about once a month. We love their lasagna, manicotti, garlic knots and pizza. Always on time and very friendly
They always have good NY style pizza. Decently priced and good for the size. Always a go to pizza place.
Who knew! $2 for a slice of cheese, tastes like anything you'd get on a NY corner. Reminds me of a pizza place we'd go to back in my hometown.
I'm from NY, and I love pizza. I ordered the NY white pizza for here and it was absolutely fantastic. There are a lot of places that claim they have NY pizza... This one actually does. From my first bite to the last I was taken back to NY. Also, you can order by the slice. While there I met the owners who were attentive and friendly. This is a must go place.
Stopped in after a football game at about 8:30pm. It was not very busy, which we found surprising. The pizza was good though. Came out pretty quick and we all enjoyed it!
4.5 stars I love Anna Maria's in Carrboro. It's my #1 go-to pizza spot, right up there with Village Pizza & Pasta in Chatham County. Ther pizza is the closest to authentic NY style pizza that you will find in Chapel Hill/Carrboro. And their white pizza is amazing--it has tons of ricotta and garlic. I'm also a huge fan of their pepperoni, broccoli and onion calzones, which can feed 2 and are packed full of toppings for only $8! Go here and grab a slice, or take home a whole pie. But make sure you go to the Chapel Hill/Carrboro location, not the one in Graham. The one in Graham is the worst--they don't cook their pizza all the way through and they barely give you any toppings.
Location
-
Hwy 54 Carrboro Plz Carrboro, NC 27510 Hotline: (919) 929-1877
Welcome to Anna Maria's Pizzeria, a hidden gem nestled in Carrboro, North Carolina. This charming establishment is a haven for pizza lovers and offers a taste of New York right in the heart of the Tar Heel State. Known for its unclaimed pizza category, Anna Maria's provides an array of options that cater to everyone, from casual diners to families looking for a delightful meal.
The pizzeria excels in providing a diverse menu filled with mouthwatering selections. Highlights include their delectable NY-style pizza, savory strombolis, and hearty pasta dishes. Each bite of their pizza transports you back to the bustling streets of New York, with diners praising the authentic taste and quality. One customer stated, "This place actually does have NY pizza," underscoring the restaurant's commitment to authenticity.
- Appetizers: Start your meal with the Sampler Platter, which includes mozzarella sticks, jalapeño peppers, onion rings, and fried ravioli, all served with rich marinara sauce. For the seafood lover, the Fried Calamari is a must-try.
- Salads: Fresh and vibrant options like the Grilled Chicken Salad and Antipasto Salad offer a refreshing complement to your meal.
- Strombolis: Customizable to your liking, the Veggie Stromboli with fresh spinach and feta is especially popular among the health-conscious diners.
- Pizza by the slice: Indulge in their iconic $2 cheese slice, perfect for a quick lunch or a late-night snack.
Anna Maria's Pizzeria is not just about food; it's also about the experience. The ambiance is quiet and classy, making it an excellent choice for groups, families, or a kid-friendly outing. The restaurant also offers outdoor seating and catering services, perfect for those larger gatherings or special events.
With amenities like Wi-Fi and private lot parking, Anna Maria's makes it easy to enjoy a delightful meal without the hassle. Delivery and takeout options are also available, allowing you to savor their culinary delights from the comfort of your own home.
If you’re in the Carrboro area and in search of excellent pizza, look no further than Anna Maria's Pizzeria. With a menu that combines quality ingredients, friendly service, and a true sense of New York style, you are bound to leave with your cravings satisfied. Don't forget to try their famed lasagna or garlic knots as well; you won’t be disappointed!
For more information or to place an order, feel free to contact them at (919) 929-1877.
